Wednesday, 15 July 2020

Can the Scenarios be balanced?

1st off I like the different dynamics of the 12 different scenarios, but balancing the scoring of them for tournaments is a bastard.

Blackjack Scoring System tries to do this by forcing them into 4TP variance according to a variable gap depending on scenario.

Northern Kings Scoring System tries to do this by positive scoring up to 5VP, but also means losing scores can vary greatly with some scenarios never being able to score as high as other scenarios.

Herts Scoring System does not combine other parts into an overall TP, but uses Scenario VP, Kills, Attrition and Strength of Schedule as deciders.

Issues:
  • Not all scenarios score the same
  • Not all scenarios have the same max table VP
  • Not all scenarios have the same max winning VP
  • Not all scenarios have the same max losing VP
  • Not all scenarios have the same highest winning VP if losing VP is at max
  • Not all scenarios have the same highest draw score
So can the scenarios be balanced?
Short answer - yes
For the how, read on.....